Nicola Pizza®, now located at at 17323 Ocean One Plaza, Lewes, Delaware. Nicola Pizza® started business in Rehoboth Beach, Delaware in 1971. Soon afterward Nicholas Caggiano, owner of Nicola Pizza®, originated the Nic-o-Boli®. He first offered it to his employees and later he sold it to his customers. An American Tradition was born... today Nick Sr, his son Nick Jr and niece Kelly still use the finest ingredients. Fats from the beef are extracted, 3 different kinds of cheeses are blended, and the sauce and dough contain no animal fat or vegetable oil... A natural homemade product. If you haven't please come in and try our Nic-o-boli or if you have made memories with us while we were downtown come try one again and make new memories at our new location.
Cuisine
PizzaRecent Reviews
Elizabeth Cole : 5 on 9/4/2026 4:50 pm We ordered BBQ wings, Hot wings, Cheese Fries, Stuffed jalapeno peppers, Mozzarella Sticks and a party pizza. The Adults all enjoyed different Crushes- Orange Pineapple, Coconut and Cherry Crush and Beer- The Birthday Guy had a Shirley Temple. The food was delicious! The whole night was wonderful! I grew up a Grottos Girl and seldom eat pizza anywhere else but my Son loves this place better and I agree it has a very nice atmosphere and everyone was so friendly!
I will be back but still love my Grottos too. Thanks to all of the staff for a fantastic dinner out!!
Ryan Miller : 5 on 8/9/2026 11:12 pm 
Ron Long : 5 on 5/12/2026 2:38 am My trip to Delaware is not complete without a trip to Nicola Pizza!!
Modal title