Nicola Pizza

0 miles

Opens at 11:00 am

Hours 11:00 am - 11:00 pm

Sunday 11:00 am - 11:00 pm
Monday 11:00 am - 11:00 pm
Tuesday 11:00 am - 11:00 pm
Wednesday 11:00 am - 11:00 pm
Thursday 11:00 am - 11:00 pm
Friday 11:00 am - 11:00 pm
Saturday 11:00 am - 11:00 pm

17323 Ocean One Plaza, Lewes, DE 19958

+1 302-226-2654

Website

Nicola Pizza®, now located at at 17323 Ocean One Plaza, Lewes, Delaware. Nicola Pizza® started business in Rehoboth Beach, Delaware in 1971. Soon afterward Nicholas Caggiano, owner of Nicola Pizza®, originated the Nic-o-Boli®. He first offered it to his employees and later he sold it to his customers. An American Tradition was born... today Nick Sr, his son Nick Jr and niece Kelly still use the finest ingredients. Fats from the beef are extracted, 3 different kinds of cheeses are blended, and the sauce and dough contain no animal fat or vegetable oil... A natural homemade product. If you haven't please come in and try our Nic-o-boli or if you have made memories with us while we were downtown come try one again and make new memories at our new location.

Cuisine

Pizza

Recent Reviews

Ocean Blue : 5 on 8/26/2025 12:22 pm

We LOVE this place, the people & the PIZZA !!! The atmosphere at the new Nicola Pizza along Coastal Highway, Lewes, is AWESOME. Always GREAT food & FRIENDLY servers. Their salads & pizza are ALWAYS delicious. During the off-season, this place has a very "local" feel - we usually run into friends & neighbors when we're here. During the peak season, it's amazing how many people Nicola's can handle comfortably. We've never had to wait to get seated, but we usually arrive just before 5 pm. I'm posting a pic, but unfortunately, there are slices missing - some people are just too anxious to DIVE INTO a Nicola pizza & we never seem to get a pic of the whole pie - LOL !!! Great place - highly recommended !!!

Richard Federbusch : 4 on 10/23/2025 9:20 pm

The pizza was not bad. I liked that they were generous with the cheese. The flavor wasn't bad, but the overwhelming cheese did drown out some of the flavor from the sauce. Additionally, I prefer a more crunchy crust; this pizza was a bit too "doughy" for my taste and was very chewy. Also, the pizza was very greasy. After each bite, I had to wipe the greasy residue off of my fingers. Service was friendly, and the pizza was ready quickly. If you are hungry and have a craving for pizza, this place will do.

Holly Shelton : 3 on 3/9/2025 5:38 am

First time visiting. Sadly not many gluten free options, but it is a pizza joint and I know this. I got the cauliflower crust 10" pizza as a white pizza. It was okay, crust was completely burnt which I was a bit sad about. It was so busy I didn'twant to wait as long as my friend did did get a new one. I personally did not feel as though I got my bang for my buck. I didn't get any toppings because each topping was an extra $2.50 on top of my already $17 pizza. I felt like the cost verses what I got was not worth it. I understand having a gluten allergy is my problem, but it's frustrating when you feel like restaurants are really over charging for way less food because of the allergy. I'm pleased my friends liked it but I personally will not go out of my way to return.